CMT Research Library

What the research says about concierge and membership medicine

This is a sourced list of published outcomes data on membership-based primary care. It covers MDVIP's own studies and surveys alongside independent peer-reviewed research and government reports, including findings that raise concerns. Every entry links to its source so you can read it yourself.

Why this page exists

Physicians thinking about a membership model hear a lot of numbers. Some come from peer-reviewed journals. Others come from press releases, or from studies written or paid for by the companies being studied. It's hard to tell which is which.

That matters because a career decision deserves clear evidence. This page groups the research by who produced it, so you can weigh each finding with that in mind.

How to read this evidence

  • Who funded it: Most of the outcomes research on the MDVIP model was written by MDVIP medical leadership or funded by MDVIP and its partners. Those studies are peer-reviewed, but they aren't independent.
  • Study design: Nearly all of these studies are observational, not randomized. Patients who choose to join a membership practice may differ from those who don't, and matching only partly corrects for that.
  • Disagreement is real: Independent economists have found that concierge enrollment raised total spending without changing mortality. Both sides are included here.
  • Not an endorsement: Concierge Medicine Today does not endorse MDVIP or any company named on this page. CMT has been an independent publication since 2007.

MDVIP peer-reviewed outcomes studies

Company-affiliated MDVIP staff wrote or co-wrote these studies, or MDVIP helped fund them.

Hospital use: 2012

American Journal of Managed Care, 2012;18(12):e453-e460

By 2010, hospital discharges for MDVIP Medicare members were 79% lower than for nonmembers, and 72% lower in the non-Medicare group (ages 35 to 64). The gap grew between 2006 and 2010.

Read the study (AJMC)

Medicare Advantage spending: 2014

Musich S, Klemes A, Kubica MA, Wang S, Hawkins K. American Journal of Managed Care, August 2014

The study compared 2,360 MDVIP members with 5,521 nonmembers in Medicare Advantage. Members cost about $1,040 less per patient in year one and $564 less in year two.

Read the AJMC summary

ER, urgent care and costs in a commercial population: 2016

Population Health Management, 2016;19(6):389-397. doi:10.1089/pop.2015.0171

The study followed 10,186 MDVIP members and matched nonmembers for up to three years. Members used the ER and urgent care less. Their medical and pharmacy costs ran higher in years one and two, and the two groups were about even by year three.

Read the full text (PubMed Central)

Medicare patients with diabetes: 2020

Morefield B, Tomai L, Slanchev V, Klemes A. American Journal of Managed Care, March 2020

The study used Medicare fee-for-service claims over five years. After enrollment, members had less outpatient spending, fewer ER visits and fewer unplanned admissions, and lower Medicare spending in year five. Office visits and the spending on them went up.

Read the study (PDF)

Cardiovascular risk screening: 2013

Future Cardiology, 2013;9(4):497-506. doi:10.2217/fca.13.27. Co-authored with Cleveland HeartLab.

The review looked at wellness panels from more than 95,000 MDVIP patients. A multimarker panel flagged some risk in 70% of patients, about 40% more than cholesterol testing alone would have found.

View the article (DOI)

An inflammation marker in pre-diabetic and diabetic patients: 2018

Alcivar-Franco D, Purvis S, Penn MS, Klemes A. Journal of International Medical Research, 2018. doi:10.1177/0300060517749111

This was a retrospective look at 285,901 patients in 801 practices from 2011 to 2015. The share testing positive for myeloperoxidase, a marker of arterial inflammation, fell in diabetic patients from 21.3% to 6.7%. Cleveland HeartLab and MDVIP funded the study. The authors note it can't show whether fewer heart attacks or strokes followed.

Read the full text (PubMed Central)

Patient satisfaction compared with traditional care: 2015

Klemes A, Solomon H. The Open Public Health Journal, 2015;8:1-9

In an online survey, 97% of MDVIP patients said they were satisfied with their relationship with their doctor. In the traditional-care comparison group, 58% said the same.

Read the study

Quality measures (HEDIS) compared with national health plans

Seligmann RE, Gassner LP, Stolzberg ND, Samarasekera NK, Warth K, Klemes A. International Journal of Person Centered Medicine

This chart review covered 15 MDVIP-affiliated physicians in Arizona. 69% of their patients had LDL cholesterol under 100, compared with 37% to 52% on national health plan benchmarks. 83% of diabetic patients had blood pressure under 140/90, compared with 50% to 65%.

Read the study

MDVIP surveys of patients and physicians

Company surveys These are surveys, not peer-reviewed studies. MDVIP ran them or paid partners to run them.

2026 Patient Satisfaction Survey

MDVIP, released via PR Newswire, August 25, 2026. 68,801 member responses, collected February 1 to March 31, 2026.

95% of members said they were satisfied with MDVIP and 97% with their physician. The Net Promoter Score was 79, the highest in the survey's history. The release also cites an analysis with Arcadia: Medicare patients had 15% fewer ER visits and 13% fewer hospital stays than expected. MDVIP notes the results may not represent all members.

Read the release

2025 Physician Health Survey (with Ipsos)

MDVIP and Ipsos. 401 primary care physicians, surveyed October 2024, released January 2025.

62% of the physicians said their patient visits feel more transactional than relational. 60% said doctors need to rebuild patients' trust after the pandemic. 49% said they lack the business skills to run a successful practice.

Read the release · Medical Economics coverage

Earlier Physician Health Survey (conducted by Ipsos Public Affairs)

Reported by Healthcare Finance News. Survey year not confirmed.

83% of primary care physicians said they were too stretched to spend enough time with patients. 54% said time pressure often led them to write prescriptions or refer to specialists. 41% had seriously considered leaving medicine because of work stress.

Read the coverage

Independent research on concierge medicine

Independent These come from academic researchers and government agencies with no stated ties to a concierge company. Several raise concerns about cost and access.

A national survey of retainer physicians: 2005

Alexander GC, Kurlander J, Wynia MK. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 2005;20(12):1079-1083. doi:10.1111/j.1525-1497.2005.0233.x

85% of retainer physicians had converted from a traditional practice, and on average kept only 12% of their former patients. 84% said they provided charity care.

View the article (DOI)

GAO's federal review of concierge care: 2005

U.S. Government Accountability Office, GAO-05-929, August 2005

The first federal study of concierge care. GAO found no widespread access problem for Medicare patients at the time, given how few concierge physicians there were.

Read the report (GAO)

Patient experience in an academic concierge practice: 2009

Ko JM, Rodriguez HP, Fairchild DG, Rodday AMC, Safran DG. The Patient: Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 2009;2(2):95-103

Four physicians who practiced in both a concierge and a general practice at the same academic medical center were studied. Concierge patients rated care coordination, access and office staff interactions more highly.

View the article (DOI)

NORC study for MedPAC: 2010

NORC at the University of Chicago, contractor report for the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, September 2010

The physicians interviewed had 100 to 425 patients each, down from more than 2,000 before. The authors noted that few studies had compared patient outcomes between retainer care and standard care.

Read the report (PDF)

Spending and mortality after concierge conversion: 2023

Candon M, David G, Leive A, et al. "On Resource Allocation in Health Care: The Case of Concierge Medicine." Journal of Health Economics, 2023

Using Medicare claims, the authors found that income predicted who joined more strongly than health status did. Enrollment brought large increases in total spending and no average change in mortality.

Read the Penn LDI summary

National growth of concierge and DPC practices: 2025

Zhu JM, et al. Health Affairs, December 2025. Harvard Medical School, OHSU and Johns Hopkins.

From 2018 to 2023, concierge and DPC practice sites grew 83.1% (from 1,658 to 3,036), and the clinicians working in them grew 78.4%. Independent ownership fell from about 84% to 60%.

Read the Harvard summary

How to use this research

1. Read the source

Open the study, not the headline. Check who funded it and who was compared to whom.

2. Weigh both sides

Put the utilization findings next to the independent spending and access research before drawing conclusions.

3. Measure your own

Track retention, access and outcomes in your own practice so you have your own evidence over time.

Stay current

New studies come out every year. Physicians who keep up can answer patients' and partners' questions with real evidence instead of marketing claims. CMT adds new research to this page as it's published.

FAQ

Why does MDVIP make up so much of this page?

MDVIP has published more peer-reviewed outcomes research on its own model than any other membership network CMT has found. If you know of studies on other models, please send them to CMT for review.

Does company-funded research mean the findings are wrong?

No. Peer review still applies. But funding and authorship are real potential conflicts, so we label them and include independent research next to them.

Is concierge medicine proven to improve health outcomes?

The evidence is mixed. Studies tied to the MDVIP model report lower hospital and ER use. An independent 2023 analysis found higher spending and no change in mortality. Researchers have consistently called for more rigorous, independent outcome studies.

How can I suggest a study?

Use the contact page. Include a link to the published source.

This page is for education and information only. It is not medical, legal, financial, tax or accounting advice. Concierge Medicine Today does not vet or endorse any company, product or practice named here, and inclusion is not an endorsement. Statistics are reported as published by each source as of November 2026; read the original sources for full methods and limitations. Please don't submit patient health information. See Terms.